I get a vote in this right? I'm sure I have more records, tapes, and CDs than some who DO have votes. In any event, I thought I'd pop off about which of these bands belongs in the HOF this time around.
BLACK SABBATH - 6th time they've been nominated, it should be a charm, and not just because of the recent popularity of Ozzy.
AC/DC - 3rd time on the ballot. As much as I like these guys, I'm not sure they belong. They sold a ton of albums, and that might be enough to sway votes, but I'll pass. They were marginally influential, but hugely successful. Not the best combination in my mind.
LYNYRD SKYNYRD - 4th time nominee ... I say its time. The band brought southern rock to its pinnacle, gaining both commercial success and influence.
SEX PISTOLS - second time nominee ... again, as much as I hate too, I have to take a pass. Maybe its just me being too focused on bands that were influential in the US. To be sure, the Pistols had their share of influence across the globe, and I'm better off for it. But longevity also has to be something of a factor ... unless maybe your Buddy Holly, which these guys ain't.
THE POLICE - definitely worthy, but do they deserve to go in on their first try?
THE CLASH - too derivative, not a big enough influence on others. Not to suggest that they aren't worthy of consideration. And yes, they did do a few new twists & tricks in rock & roll, but it would be like calling Van Halen original because he did that two-hand tapping thing.
MC5 - where would glam rock be without these guys? One of my fave oldtimer bands, and hard to downplay the significance they had on a subgenre of rock, but I'm not sure its enough to warrant inclusion in the HOF.
ELVIS COSTELLO - I know in my heart that he belongs, but I can't quite find the words to make the case. Elvis has always been one who, although not my cup of tea, I had to keep my ear on what he was doing just to be sure I was never left behind. When it comes down to it, I think he'll get in, but maybe after a few more ballots.
STEVE WINWOOD - I love the man's work, but once again, depending on what the voters looks at, he'll either have to wait a few more ballots, or he'll never get in. Maybe next time.

1 Comments
IT SEEMS TO ME THAT MORE AND MORE I SEE THESE NOMINATIONS I BEGIN TO BELIEVE THAT THIS R & R HOF THING IS NOTHING BUT POLITICAL. MAKES YOU WONDER WHO THE HECK IS PUTTING IN SOME OF THESE ARTISTS. NOT TO SAY THEY ARE ALL BAD BUT WHAT P'S ME OFF IS WHY FOR THE LOVE A MIKE THERE HAS NOT EVEN BEEN A NOMINATION FOR CHICAGO. WHO CAN SAY THEY DON'T BELONG. THIS R & R HOF THING MUST BE RUN BY DICK CLARK. i DON'T KNOW WHAT THEY LOOK AT WHEN NOMINATING BUT SOMEONE AIN'T LOOKIN IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION. i JUST HAD TO VENT, SORRY IF I OFFEND